McCall's Tavern
About McCall's Tavern
If looking for a cozy spot to unwind and indulge in some delicious comfort food, then McCall’s Tavern in Lady Lake, Florida, should definitely be on the radar. Nestled at 997 Alverez Ave, this charming tavern emanates a warm, inviting atmosphere that’s perfect for casual dinners or catching up with friends over a couple of drinks.
The moment stepping inside, there’s a sense of friendly familiarity. The décor offers a rustic vibe with wooden accents and comfortable seating, making it easy to settle in and feel right at home. Sporting various local memorabilia and an overall laid-back feel, it’s no wonder that locals and visitors alike are drawn to this gem.
Now, let’s chat about the food because that’s what really pulls folks into a tavern, right? The menu is a delightful mix of classic favorites and unique twists. Appetizers like loaded nachos and buffalo wings are perfect for kicking off the meal. For the main event, the burgers here receive rave reviews. Juicy patties come stacked high with delicious toppings, making each bite a juicy explosion of flavor. And don’t forget about the hand-cut fries that accompany many of these dishes – they’re golden and crispy, a perfect sidekick to any meal.
If something lighter is in order, the tavern also offers a solid selection of salads and wraps. The grilled chicken Caesar salad is a popular choice, balancing taste and health quite effectively. Pairing any dish with one of their craft beers or a signature cocktail elevates the dining experience even further.
Customers have consistently praised McCall’s Tavern for its friendly service. The staff is known for being attentive without being overbearing, creating an ideal dining atmosphere. Whether dining solo, with a date, or in a larger group, the service maintains a casual and approachable vibe that adds to the overall enjoyment.
In terms of location, being situated in Lady Lake means that the tavern attracts a mix of residents and visitors, making it a vibrant place to gather. It’s also conveniently located near various other attractions, making it a great pit stop after a day of exploring the area. Plus, there’s often lively music or events happening that really bring the community together.
All in all, McCall’s Tavern stands out as a fantastic spot that combines hearty meals, a welcoming environment, and top-notch service. Whether in the mood for a lazy afternoon or a lively evening, this tavern might just become a new local favorite.
McCall's Tavern Photos






Customer Reviews
Kyle Cyr
A Great Spot with an Even Better Patio Vibe
Stopped by with some friends for lunch during the downtown art festival, and the patio atmosphere was perfect—such a great place to relax and soak in the energy of the event.
Even though the staff seemed a bit short-handed and service was a little slow, our server handled it all with a smile and was genuinely helpful and kind.
The food more than made up for the wait—absolutely delicious!
Overall, a really enjoyable experience.
I’d definitely come back, especially during downtown events.
Lillian Narramore
We used to love coming to McCall’s, but the service at this establishment is totally gone!
Last night we were never asked if we wanted a drink, never got a menu, I went and found some menus, but nobody came to take drink or food orders!
My husband and our friend finally after 45 min got up and chased down one of the two servers who then took the food orders.
It took 55 min before our friend approached the server asking about our food. She was standing there eating something. She had forgotten, ran into the kitchen and came out with our food. The chicken was so dry it was obvious it had been sitting under the heat lamp for quite a while!
We got no silverware or napkins, I again got up to find napkins. No drink orders taken. My husband and our friend finally got to the bar to get something to drink after we were done eating.
Everyone were upset at this lack of service.
How do you make money when drink or food orders are not taken?
We will come back, but we’ll eat at home and bring a water bottle.
So we’ll just sit there taking up a table enjoying the music and dancing which I feel is wrong, but what can one do?
We were told people get up and leave without paying after finally eating because the server never comes back to check on anything!
McCall’s used to be so great! Not so anymore, unfortunately!
Kim Marie Dominiak
This was their 2nd chance .. idk if I totally blame the severs or management , as sitting outside w our dog we waited over 20 min for someone to wait on us, another 15 min to get 2 drinks and never saw our sever again. Someone else brought out food and we had no utensils or napkins
Flagged down a few others asking for water and a water for our dog and never got it . Food is eh. Nothing special .. sides were lukewarm . Been here well over an hour and we’d never come back, and we’ve asked for the check and still no response
Sorry. Step up your service and taste !
Contact & Location
ADDRESS
997 Alverez Ave, Lady Lake, FL 32159, USA
PHONE
(352) 561-3461
OPENING HOURS
Monday: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM